What is the difference between high-, middle-, and low-range theories? Explain your understanding of a middle-range nursing theory. Identify a research study in which a middle-range theory was applied. Discuss the study results and implications for practice.
Expert Solution Preview
Introduction:
In the field of nursing, theories are vital frameworks that guide and shape practice. They provide nurses with a systematic approach to understanding patient care and help in developing evidence-based interventions. There are varying levels of nursing theories, including high-range, middle-range, and low-range theories. This answer will explore the differences between these theories, define a middle-range nursing theory, identify a research study that utilized a middle-range theory, and discuss the study’s results and implications for practice.
Difference between high-, middle-, and low-range theories:
High-range theories, also known as grand theories, are broad in scope and attempt to explain complex phenomena or address numerous aspects of nursing practice. These theories often provide a broad perspective on nursing and may not be directly testable. Examples of high-range nursing theories include Dorothy Johnson’s Behavioral System Model and Betty Neuman’s Systems Model.
On the other hand, middle-range theories are narrower in focus and address more specific phenomena within nursing practice. They are often derived from high-range theories and provide a bridge between grand theories and nursing practice. Middle-range theories are more testable and offer practical applications. These theories can provide a framework for developing strategies to address specific nursing problems. A prime example of a middle-range theory is Dorothea Orem’s Self-Care Deficit Theory.
Low-range theories, also known as practice theories, are more specific and concrete. They guide clinical practice and offer practical guidelines for nursing interventions. These theories are narrower in scope, focusing on specific patient populations or healthcare situations. Examples of low-range theories include Patricia Benner’s Novice to Expert Theory and Jean Watson’s Theory of Human Caring.
Understanding of a middle-range nursing theory:
A middle-range nursing theory is a theory that focuses on a narrower aspect of nursing practice, often stemming from a broader grand theory. It provides a framework to address specific nursing phenomena and guide evidence-based interventions.
For instance, Dorothea Orem’s Self-Care Deficit Theory is a middle-range nursing theory that posits that individuals have the ability and responsibility to engage in self-care activities necessary for their health and well-being. According to this theory, nursing care should be centered around empowering patients to perform self-care to the fullest extent possible. Nurses can assess patients’ self-care abilities and provide intervention strategies to bridge the gap between self-care deficits and optimal health outcomes.
Research study utilizing a middle-range theory and its implications for practice:
One research study that applied a middle-range nursing theory is “A Randomized Controlled Trial of a Self-Management Intervention for Adults with Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: A Middle-Range Nursing Theory Perspective” by Chiu et al. (2016).
In this study, the middle-range nursing theory of self-management was employed to investigate the effectiveness of a self-management intervention for adults with type 2 diabetes. The intervention aimed to enhance participants’ self-care abilities, including self-monitoring of blood glucose, dietary control, exercise, and medication adherence.
The study found that the participants who received the self-management intervention had significantly improved glycemic control, self-care behaviors, and quality of life compared to the control group. These results highlight the clinical relevance of applying middle-range nursing theories to guide interventions in managing chronic conditions like type 2 diabetes.
The implications for practice based on the study’s findings suggest that incorporating self-management interventions guided by middle-range nursing theories can lead to improved outcomes for individuals with type 2 diabetes. Nurses can utilize the principles of self-management theory to develop tailored interventions and empower patients in managing their disease effectively.
Overall, middle-range nursing theories serve as valuable frameworks for addressing specific nursing phenomena and improving patient outcomes. They provide nurses with practical guidance to develop evidence-based interventions and contribute to the advancement of nursing practice.
